Amy Paternite
Partner, Realtor® Sales Associate

Amy Paternite
Partner, Realtor® Sales Associate

Licensing: NJ 0678631

Amy Paternite is a Partner and Global Luxury Certified Agent at The Good Life Group at Coldwell Banker, the #1 ranked real estate team in Maplewood in 2025 by Real Trends Verified and the #1 top-producing team at Coldwell Banker Maplewood since the team's founding in November 2022. With 20 years as a licensed REALTOR® and a 5 Star Professional award winner for over a decade, the Good Life Group serves Maplewood, South Orange, West Orange, Bloomfield, Montclair, Glen Ridge, Summit, Millburn, Short Hills, Livingston, and Morristown—primarily NYC suburbs along the NJ Transit Midtown Direct line with a commute under an hour to NY Penn Station.

Amy and her partner, Ben Garrison, also Global Luxury Certified, along with teammate Sara Brown, close 40+ transactions annually and achieved $42M in sales volume in 2025. While the average home in the South Orange/Maplewood (SOMA) market sold at 111% of asking price, The Good Life Group averaged 123% of asking price, outperforming the SOMA market by 12%, a performance unmatched by any other team.

A recipient of the NCJAR Circle of Excellence every year since 2009, Amy has built a reputation for unbeatable local wisdom, innovative marketing, and tough negotiation in New Jersey's competitive residential market. With 101 five-star Google reviews and 151 five-star Zillow reviews, Amy and The Good Life Group deliver a boutique, concierge-level experience for clients buying and selling homes and first-time properties, with an average price point exceeding $1M. Amy's extensive network of contractors, tradespeople, and fellow agents, combined with her detail-obsessed team, ensures seamless logistics and full-suite marketing at every stage of the transaction.

Before discovering her passion for real estate in 2006, Amy spent a decade as the owner of a boutique music industry public relations firm, honing the problem-solving and negotiating skills that now benefit her clients daily. A South Orange resident since 2003, Amy is deeply involved in her community, volunteering weekly at The Interfaith Food Pantry of The Oranges, serving on the JCRC of Jewish Federation of Greater MetroWest, and supporting the Achieve Foundation for the SOMA School District. Amy lives in the Newstead neighborhood of South Orange with her husband Ryan, two children, and their dog Cheech.

ALL LISTINGS

FEATURED LISTINGS

To show communities in this section, add an agent subdomain to the community (in any community collection) set to:
amy.thegoodlifegroupnj.com


CONTACT Amy Paternite

Name: Coldwell Banker Maplewood

Address: 145 Maplewood Avenue Maplewood, NJ, 07040

Mobile Phone: (917) 442-5130

Office Phone:  (973) 378-2284

Email: amy@amypaternite.com

Hours of Operation:

Monday - 9:00am-6:00pm

Tuesday - 9:00am-6:00pm

Wednesday - by appointment

Thursday - 9:00am-6:00pm

Friday - 9:00am-6:00pm

Saturday - by appointment

Sunday - by appointment